Text messages, Facebook posts, Instagram messages, Snapchat conversations, emails, and other digital communications have become routine evidence in Illinois criminal cases.
A prosecutor may have screenshots of a conversation, photographs of social-media posts, or messages extracted from a phone.
But the fact that something appears on a phone or social-media account does not automatically answer the question of whether it can be used as evidence in court.
Digital evidence can raise important questions about authentication, context, hearsay, privacy, and how the evidence was obtained.
Can Text Messages Be Used as Evidence?
Yes.
Text messages can be admitted as evidence in a criminal case when the prosecution can establish the requirements for admissibility.
One important issue is authentication—establishing that the messages are what the prosecution claims they are.
A screenshot showing a person's name at the top of a conversation does not necessarily establish, by itself, who actually wrote the messages.
Depending upon the circumstances, authentication may involve testimony, distinctive characteristics of the conversation, phone records, admissions, or other evidence connecting the messages to the alleged sender.
The specific method depends upon the evidence and circumstances of the case.
What About Screenshots?
Screenshots are common, but they can raise questions.
A screenshot may show only part of a conversation.
It may not show:
The messages immediately before or after the statement;
Who initiated the conversation;
The date or time;
Whether messages were deleted;
Whether the screenshot was edited or altered; or
The identity of the person using the account.
Context can matter considerably.
A single sentence removed from a lengthy conversation may have a substantially different meaning from the conversation as a whole.
What About Social-Media Posts?
Public social-media posts can potentially be used as evidence just like other forms of evidence.
But prosecutors still generally need to establish that the account or post is actually connected to the defendant and that the evidence satisfies the applicable rules of evidence.
This can become particularly important when:
Multiple people have access to an account;
A username does not clearly identify the person;
The account has been hacked;
Someone else had access to the defendant's phone; or
The prosecution has only a screenshot rather than the original information.
The question is not simply whether a post exists.
It is whether the prosecution can establish what the post is, who created it, and what it actually proves.
Can Deleted Messages Be Recovered?
Sometimes.
Deleting a message does not necessarily mean that every copy of the information has disappeared.
Depending upon the circumstances, digital evidence may exist on a phone, computer, cloud account, backup, another participant's device, or through records maintained by a service provider.
The availability of that information varies significantly by platform and circumstance.
This is one reason defendants should not assume that deleting a message necessarily eliminates it as potential evidence.
What If Police Search Your Phone?
This creates a separate constitutional issue.
A person's phone can contain enormous amounts of private information, and the United States Supreme Court has recognized that searching the digital contents of a cell phone generally requires a warrant, subject to recognized exceptions.
In Riley v. California, the Supreme Court held that police generally may not search the digital contents of a cell phone seized from an arrested person without a warrant.
That does not mean every search of every phone is unconstitutional. Consent, a warrant, exigent circumstances, and other legal doctrines can affect the analysis.
But a phone is not simply another piece of physical property.
Can Police Get Your Social-Media Messages Without Your Permission?
Potentially, yes.
Law enforcement can seek digital information through legal process, including warrants and subpoenas where appropriate.
The exact process depends upon the type of information sought, the service involved, and the applicable law.
The fact that the defendant did not personally hand the information to police therefore does not necessarily mean the prosecution cannot obtain it.
What About Messages Between Two People?
A common misconception is that a private conversation is automatically protected from being used as evidence.
That is not necessarily the case.
If one participant voluntarily provides messages to police, the constitutional analysis may be very different from a situation where police obtain information by searching a person's phone without proper legal authority.
Likewise, the rules governing evidence and the rules governing searches are separate questions.
A message can potentially be authentic and relevant while still raising a separate question about how police obtained it.
Context Can Be Just as Important as Authenticity
Suppose prosecutors introduce a message saying:
"I'll take care of it."
That statement could mean very different things depending upon the conversation surrounding it.
Was the person talking about money?
A child?
A business matter?
A fight?
Something illegal?
The prosecution may argue that the message has a particular meaning.
The defense may argue that the surrounding conversation shows something completely different.
For this reason, digital evidence should generally be examined in context rather than reduced to isolated screenshots.
What If the Messages Are Embarrassing but Not Criminal?
Being embarrassing, offensive, or suspicious is not necessarily the same thing as being evidence of a crime.
Criminal evidence generally must have some connection to an issue in the case, and other rules of evidence may limit what can be presented to a jury or judge.
A defendant's entire digital life does not automatically become admissible simply because police obtained access to a phone or account.
The relevance and admissibility of particular evidence remain separate questions.
What Happens When Digital Evidence Is Central to a Case?
Digital evidence can be powerful for either side.
A prosecution may use messages or social-media posts to establish:
Identity;
Intent;
Knowledge;
Communications between alleged participants;
Timeline;
Location;
Relationships; or
Statements allegedly acknowledging criminal conduct.
The defense may challenge the evidence based upon authenticity, context, relevance, hearsay, the manner in which it was obtained, or other evidentiary and constitutional issues.
Sometimes the most important evidence is not the message itself but what happened before and after it.
Don't Assume a Screenshot Tells the Whole Story
Digital evidence can look extremely convincing on a computer screen.
But criminal cases require more than something looking convincing.
Questions can arise about:
Who created the message;
Whether the account belonged to the defendant;
Whether someone else had access;
Whether the screenshot is complete;
Whether the conversation was altered;
Whether additional messages provide important context;
How police obtained the information; and
Whether the evidence satisfies the applicable rules of evidence.
Those questions can become particularly important when a prosecution depends heavily on electronic communications.
Digital Evidence Is Now Part of Criminal Defense
Phones and social-media accounts can provide prosecutors with evidence that did not exist in many criminal cases a generation ago.
But digital evidence is still evidence.
It must be evaluated under the Constitution and the rules governing admissibility.
A text message, screenshot, or social-media post may be important evidence in a criminal case—but its existence does not end the legal analysis.
For more information about constitutional protections during police investigations, see our articles on searches of phones and electronic devices, police questioning, and searches of vehicles in Illinois.
Illinois Criminal Defense Representation
The Law Offices of Richard Waller represents clients throughout Cook, DuPage, Lake, and Will Counties in Illinois criminal cases, including cases involving digital evidence, drug charges, weapons offenses, DUI, theft, domestic offenses, and other criminal allegations.
If digital communications are being used as evidence in a criminal case, an experienced defense attorney can evaluate both the evidence itself and the circumstances under which it was obtained.
Call: (847) 790-4042
Email: richard@wallerlawoffice.com
Free consultations are available.
Say Nothing, Call Me.®